Every false story promises protection. Every false story eventually demands payment.
“A man sees the truth / But believes the lies.”
~ U2, “Slow Dancing”
Most of us think of lies as things we tell other people. We think of deception as a deliberate act: hiding what happened, changing the details, saying something we know isn’t true. Those lies matter. But I’m not convinced they are the ones that do the most damage.
Some of the lies that shape us most are the ones we have stopped recognizing as lies.
I’m fine. This doesn’t affect me. I can stop whenever I want. This is just who I am. If people really knew me, they wouldn’t respect me. God couldn’t forgive this.
I doubt many of us sat down one morning and decided to believe these things. More often, we arrived at them gradually. Something hurt. Something frightened us. We failed at something that mattered, did something we were ashamed of, or discovered something about ourselves we didn’t particularly want to know. Somewhere along the way, we found an explanation that made it easier to live with.
That explanation may have helped for a while. There is a reason we hold on to these stories. They do something for us. A man who tells himself his drinking is under control doesn’t have to consider giving it up. A man convinced that his anger is justified doesn’t have to ask what it is doing to his family. If I can convince myself that someone else is responsible for the resentment I have carried for years, I don’t have to examine my part in keeping it alive.
The trouble is that none of those explanations changes what is actually happening. That is where the bill begins to come due.
Every lie promises protection. Every lie eventually demands payment.
Reality Always Wins
In the Belt of Truth, I argued that biblical truth is bigger than getting the facts right. It has to do with reality itself: God as He actually is, the world He actually made, who we actually are, and what is actually going on around us.
We can misunderstand that reality. We can deny it. We can become quite skilled at explaining it away. What we cannot do is change it by refusing to acknowledge it.
A man may insist that his drinking isn’t affecting his marriage, but his wife is still living with it. He may have good reasons for losing his temper, but his children may still learn to judge whether it is safe to speak by watching his face when he walks through the door. Debt does not disappear because we stop opening the statements. Neither does an addiction, a damaged friendship, a compromised conscience, or a marriage we have been neglecting.
There is nothing especially theological about gravity. Step off a roof and gravity will behave exactly as gravity behaves, regardless of what you believe about it. Reality has that same stubborn quality. It does not adjust itself to accommodate the stories we tell. Usually the consequences aren’t immediate, which can fool us. There may be no dramatic collapse. We get through another day, then another year. The marriage survives. Nobody discovers the secret. The credit card still works. We are still functioning at work. Maybe we decide things cannot be that bad.
But false stories are purchased on credit, and the interest accumulates quietly.
One of the first things they can cost us is our ability to recognize what is true. If I have spent years explaining why my anger is justified, I am not likely to welcome someone telling me I am an angry man. If I need to believe that I have been treated unfairly, I will notice every piece of evidence that confirms it. Evidence pointing the other direction becomes surprisingly easy to dismiss.
Eventually, we can become more interested in preserving our explanation than discovering whether it is true.
That is fertile ground for spiritual deception. The enemy doesn’t need to convince me that God doesn’t exist. A distorted picture of God will do. So will a distorted picture of myself. If I believe God is withholding something good from me, that obedience cannot be trusted, or that my desires are a better guide than what God has said, I can do plenty of damage while still believing in God.
A Different Story About God
The serpent’s opening move in Genesis 3 is familiar enough that it is easy to read past it: “Did God really say…?”
He does not try to persuade Eve that there is no God. Instead, he gives her another way of interpreting the God she already knows. Maybe God is withholding something. Maybe His command isn’t protection but restriction. Maybe obedience is costing her something she ought to have.
The tree hasn’t changed. God hasn’t changed. The command hasn’t changed. What has changed is the story Eve believes about all three. Then she acts according to that story.
I think we sometimes make temptation more mysterious than it is. Most of us would have trouble deliberately choosing something we genuinely believed would destroy us. Give us a story that makes the same choice seem reasonable, deserved, necessary, or harmless, and the calculation changes considerably.
We know some of these stories because we have heard them often enough:
- God is holding out on you.
- You need this.
- You deserve this.
- No one will know.
- You’re too far gone now.
- This is simply the way you are.
The wording changes with the circumstances. The method hasn’t changed much since Eden.
This is where the Belt essay’s distinction between belief and behavior matters. Behavior is the fruit. Belief is the root. By the time a lie has settled deeply enough into us, we may no longer experience ourselves as choosing falsehood. We are simply behaving consistently with the world as we have come to believe it is.
Keeping the Story Alive
The strange thing about truth is that it doesn’t require much maintenance. What happened happened. What is true remains true whether I acknowledge it or not. A false story requires considerably more work.
Anyone who has hidden something for a long time knows this. You remember what you told one person and what you told another. Certain subjects become uncomfortable. Questions that ought to be innocent feel threatening. You become careful about what people see. Sometimes you find yourself getting defensive before anyone has actually accused you of anything.
The same kind of editing can happen without a deliberate secret. Most of us learn how to present ourselves. I know I have. We know which parts are easy to show and which parts need some work before anyone sees them. We can say “I’m good” almost automatically. Sometimes we keep busy because being busy is easier than being quiet. And most of us have at least one question we hope nobody asks.
None of that necessarily begins with an intention to deceive. That is part of what makes it difficult to recognize. Over time, though, the thing that once helped us protect ourselves becomes something we have to protect. We start organizing parts of life around keeping the story intact.
This is one reason truth can feel threatening. Telling it may cost us something. We may have to apologize without explaining ourselves. We may have to admit that a habit is no longer under control, that we were wrong about someone, that we have been blaming another person for something that belongs to us, or that the version of ourselves we have been presenting is incomplete.
That can be painful. So we postpone it. Meanwhile, the maintenance continues.
What Hiding Does to Us
A man can be well known and still not feel known.
He may have friends, a good marriage, children who love him, colleagues who respect him, people at church who depend on him. None of that guarantees that he believes those people know the man underneath the useful, competent version they usually see.
Sometimes there is a large secret behind that feeling. Often there isn’t. Years of small edits can accomplish the same thing. We minimize what is going badly, make the success sound a little better, move quickly past the subjects that make us uncomfortable, and get very good at presenting the parts of ourselves we think other people will accept.
Then an odd thing happens. People may genuinely love us, but we have trouble trusting their love because we know what they don’t. The question underneath it is difficult to silence: Would they feel the same way if they really knew me?
We hoped the mask would protect us from rejection. Instead, it made intimacy harder. We cannot insist that no one see us and then wonder why no one knows us.
I think this helps explain why confession occupies such an important place in Christian life. I used to think of confession primarily as admitting wrongdoing to God, which of course it is. But there is something else happening there. Confession is where we finally stop telling two different stories.
God already knows what happened. He knows what I wanted, what I did, why I did it, what I am afraid of, and what I have been trying not to admit. Confession is the point at which I stop trying to maintain a different account. For once, there is only one story.
What We Are Becoming
The cost that concerns me most is what happens while all of this is going on.
We are being formed whether we pay attention to it or not. What we repeatedly do becomes easier to do again, and what we repeatedly excuse eventually becomes easier to excuse. After a while, the explanation can arrive before the guilt does. Hiding can become normal enough that we stop noticing we are doing it.
A lie believed can eventually become a lie inhabited.
This is bigger than getting caught or feeling guilty. We can build years of our lives around something that was never true in the first place. Worse, we can become people shaped by the effort required to keep believing it.
That matters if the Christian life is, among other things, the long work of being formed into the likeness of Christ. We cannot become who Christ is making us while spending our energy protecting the person we are afraid to let Him change.
I don’t mean that we should become endlessly suspicious of ourselves, examining every motive until we are paralyzed. I mean something much more ordinary: we need to remain correctable.
Scripture needs to be allowed to tell us we are wrong. So do the people who know us well. Prayer needs enough silence in it for uncomfortable things to surface. When the Holy Spirit puts His finger on something we have spent a long time explaining away, perhaps our first response should not be another explanation.
Sometimes what comes into view is not flattering: I was wrong. I hurt someone. I am jealous. This habit has more control over me than I have admitted. I am angrier than I thought. I wanted people to think better of me than was true.
At least now we have something real to work with.
There is another side to this that matters just as much. Some false stories do not protect our pride. They attack it.
I am a failure. I will always be this way. What happened to me defines me. God has had enough of me. I have nothing left to offer.
We can mistake these thoughts for honesty because they are severe. Christians can even mistake them for humility. But harshness is not a test of truth. If God has not said it, agreeing with it does not make us humble.
The lie can flatter us or condemn us. Either way, it asks us to live in a world God did not make.
Coming Into the Light
After Adam and Eve believe the serpent and eat from the tree, they hide. That part of the story makes more sense to me the older I get. Hiding is what we do when the person we are and the person we want others to see are no longer quite the same.
We still find plenty of places to hide. Some of mine probably wouldn’t look like hiding from the outside. Work can do it. Staying useful can do it. So can humor, competence, independence, or filling the calendar so completely that there is little time left to think. Even good Christian activity can become another place to avoid something we know needs attention.
That makes John’s language about walking in the light more interesting to me. He writes, “If we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship with one another” (1 John 1:7).
I might expect a verse about coming into the light to end with judgment or exposure. John points toward fellowship.
That does not mean telling the truth is painless. Sometimes there is an invoice waiting. Trust may need to be rebuilt. An apology may be overdue. A habit we have defended for years may finally have to go. The people affected by our choices are not required to pretend the damage never happened simply because we finally admitted it.
But now we are dealing with what is real.
That is a very different kind of cost from continuing to maintain the lie.
That is one of the mercies of confession. God is not asking us to manufacture a better version of ourselves before we come out of hiding. He is asking us to stop hiding.
Reality never required the performance in the first place. And reality belongs to God.
Field Exercise: Find the Story
Set aside ten quiet minutes this week. Don’t start by trying to identify every failure in your life. Pick one place where something feels harder to maintain than it should.
Where am I pretending? Look for a gap between what is true and what you want other people, or perhaps yourself, to believe.
What story am I trying to keep intact? Put it into a sentence if you can. Don’t build a case for it. Just try to name it.
What is this costing me? Think beyond consequences. What is it doing to your peace, relationships, energy, integrity, or relationship with God?
Then tell God what is actually true. If someone else needs the truth from you, you probably already know who that is.
You do not have to repair everything in an afternoon. You do have to stop pretending before anything can really be repaired.
Prayer for the Courage to Live in the Light
Father, I have become good at explaining some things I should simply admit. Show me where I have preferred a safer story to what is true, including the stories that make me look better and the ones that make me smaller than You say I am.
Give me the courage to see what is actually there. Where I owe an apology, help me make it without defending myself. Where I am hiding something, bring it into the light. Where I have believed something about You that is not true, correct me.
I do not want to spend my life protecting a version of myself You are trying to change. Teach me to trust that there is more freedom in the truth, even when it costs me something, than there will ever be in hiding.
Amen.
The Full Armor of God
- Armor of God Series Overview: Born Into A War
- The Belt of Truth
- The Cost of Living a Lie | Field Note
- The Breastplate of Righteousness
- The Shoes of the Gospel of Peace
- The Shield of Faith
- The Helmet of Salvation
- The Sword of the Spirit
- Prayer
- Stand Firm
Leave a Reply