“Avoid Extremes”: Franklin’s Definition of Moderation
“Avoid extremes; forbear resenting injuries so much as you think they deserve.” ~ Benjamin Franklin
Franklin’s ninth virtue, Moderation, appears simple. In practice, it is demanding.
He was not advocating dullness or compromise. He was pursuing proportion. Moderation for Franklin meant self-command. It meant the ability to remain centered in the presence of provocation, ambition, appetite, and pride.
His phrase “forbear resenting injuries” reveals the deeper layer. Moderation is not merely about food or drink. It governs emotional reaction, wounded ego, and the instinct to retaliate.
Justice without moderation becomes vengeance.
Conviction without moderation becomes self-righteousness.
Ambition without moderation becomes compulsion.
Franklin understood this because he lived it. He possessed a sharp mind and a sharper pen. His political life demanded restraint. In a volatile colonial world, moderation was not weakness. It was strength under governance.
Moderation in the Classical Tradition
Franklin’s thinking did not arise in isolation. It stood in a long philosophical lineage.
Aristotle and the Golden Mean
Aristotle called moderation sōphrosynē and described virtue as the “golden mean” between excess and deficiency. Courage lies between cowardice and recklessness. Generosity lies between stinginess and waste.
Stoic Harmony
The Stoics spoke of inner harmony, the alignment of reason and impulse. Emotion was not suppressed but disciplined. Reaction was measured, not explosive.
Christian Echoes
Christian moral tradition later echoed the same principle in gentleness and meekness. Strength that does not need to dominate. Power that remains governed.
Franklin stood at the crossroads of Enlightenment rationalism and classical virtue ethics. Moderation for him was civic wisdom as much as personal discipline.
Finding the Mean in Real Life
Theory is clean. Life is not.
This week revealed the pendulum:
- Overreaction versus withdrawal
- Overwork versus lethargy
- Self-criticism versus avoidance
Moderation begins with noticing. Not control. Attention.
When frustration surfaced, the instinct was to explain more forcefully. To sharpen the argument. To win clarity by volume.
Instead, restraint carried the day.
Franklin once wrote that silence gains more by patience than contradiction. This echoes his second principle in The Virtue of Silence: How Franklin’s Second Principle Builds Disciplined Leadership. The pause became strength.
Moderation tells me I have nothing to prove.
That is the center.
A man with nothing to prove does not rush. He does not overstate. He does not resent every slight. Calm earns trust because it signals security.
Learning the Measure of Enough
Moderation extends beyond emotion into appetite.
Food. Work. Productivity. Creativity. Even self-improvement can become excess.
The midweek insight was simple: zeal becomes imbalance when gratitude disappears.
Enough is not scarcity. It is peace.
Franklin practiced moderation to guard against endless ambition. He was industrious, yes, but he sought sustainability. Without moderation, even Industry turns into exhaustion.
Resentment also surfaced. The ego’s appetite can be more dangerous than physical hunger.
Choosing calm professionalism over irritation restored proportion. Franklin’s instruction to “forbear resenting injuries” is not passivity. It is governance of the self.
Forgiveness reduces the echo before anger multiplies.
Rhythm, Rest, and the Still Center
Moderation lives in time.
Intentional rest restored clarity. Margin strengthened focus. Work without rhythm produces agitation. Rhythm produces steadiness.
Franklin structured his days carefully, but he left room for reflection. Moderation protects against both frenzy and drift.
By the end of the week, moderation had shifted from rule to reflex.
Naming feelings.
Choosing curiosity over reaction.
Acting instead of ruminating.
Moderation became a center to return to.
Why Moderation Still Matters Today
Modern culture rewards extremes. Loud opinions. Exhaustion as status. Constant productivity.
Moderation resists both chaos and apathy.
It keeps conviction from becoming cruelty.
It keeps ambition from becoming addiction.
It keeps justice from becoming retaliation.
Franklin’s ninth virtue remains a stabilizing force in a culture addicted to amplification.
Moderation is not halfway living. It is disciplined living.
Steady, not stagnant.
Firm, but gentle.
Strong, but governed.
That is emotional self-command.
Key Aspects of Moderation
- Balance of Mind and Emotion: Moderation brings thought and feeling into proportion. It steadies passion without extinguishing it.
- Measured Reaction: It tempers response—choosing reason over impulse.
- Conviction Without Harshness: It holds truth firmly but with kindness.
- Sufficiency and Gratitude: It teaches satisfaction before excess begins.
- Forgiveness Over Resentment: It releases the burdens of injury and offense.
- Rhythm of Rest and Work: It paces effort with renewal; motion with stillness.
Developing the Virtue
- Observe Extremes
Notice where your pendulum swings—emotionally, physically, mentally. Awareness precedes balance. - Delay Reaction
When heat rises, wait. Five seconds of quiet is often the strongest response. - Redefine “Enough”
Practice gratitude before reaching for more. Satisfaction is wealth. - Forgive Quickly
Release resentment before it multiplies. Forgiveness restores proportion. - Respect Rest
Rest is not absence but rhythm. Build margin into your days. - Return to the Center
When you feel scattered, pause and breathe. Stillness is the compass of moderation.
The Still Center
To live moderately is not to live halfway. It is to move through life with rhythm, composure, and proportion; to let strength be gentle and conviction be calm. Moderation does not erase passion; it refines it. It is what keeps energy from becoming frenzy, work from becoming compulsion, conviction from becoming pride.
Franklin pursued moderation not to dull life, but to make it sustainable. He wanted peace without apathy, action without agitation, joy without excess. In that pursuit, he found something that still speaks centuries later: the quiet freedom of self-command.
Reflection for the Week Ahead
What would it look like to carry this still center forward into your decisions, your speech, and your pace? To let moderation set the rhythm, not the rules?
Steady, not stagnant. Firm, but gentle.
That is the heart of moderation.
Continue the Franklin Virtues Series
Franklin’s 13 Virtues Series Overview | Justice | Cleanliness
Chase The Kangaroo 
Leave a reply to Thirteen Weeks, Thirteen Virtues – Chase The Kangaroo Cancel reply